I have been tasked with an exciting goal for this new fiscal year. Determine whether our existing SQL Server tools, Redgate DBA/Backup Bundle and Toad for SQL Server, are the best tools for our needs. In other words, should we continue to pay for these tools or should we purchase different tools.

Before working for this employer, I have never been able to buy additional tools so I personally do not have any experience with any other tools.  Therefore, frankly, I love the Redgate tools, but I do not know how well they stack up against tools from other vendors.  Any input from my #SQLFamily would be greatly appreciated. Enjoy!